It is a truth universally acknowledged that given two pies by two different cooks, the pie you like better belongs to the person you want to fuck more. So, when Mason Lear and Maya Kendrick discover that they both have their eyes on bisexual beefcake Damien Stone, they decide to settle things the old-fashioned way: competitive baking. Things take a turn for all three of our horny heroes when Damien ends up with a lot of pie on his face, and a lot of hungry holes fighting for his cock. Damien fucks both of the athletic roommates right there on the dining room floor, and everyone comes out with a better understanding of the importance of sharing.